Vantage Point: Insure and Regulate—Elevation Matters
Written by Wendy Lathrop, LS, CFM
Wednesday, 19 March 2008
A 89Kb PDF of this article as it appeared in the magazine—complete with images—is available by clicking HERE
I receive a lot of e-mails and calls from surveyors and others working in floodplains. From the gist of their questions there seems to be little understanding that just because a structure is constructed in compliance with technical regulations does not mean that it will be exempted from mandatory flood insurance purchase requirements. Basically, you can almost always have anything you want but you have to pay the price. You want to build a three-story mansion on a coastal barrier island? Go right ahead but don't expect to purchase federal flood insurance, and remember that without flood insurance of some sort you will not be eligible for disaster assistance. You want to place fill in the flood fringe along the river, and then build a house with the lowest floor a foot below base flood elevation? Sure, you can do it (providing that your state and local community will issue such fill permits), but your insurance premiums will be sky high.
Permission to build does not equate to exemption from flood insurance requirements. Aside from government construction and a few other minor exemptions, anyone paying a loan for which a structure in the 1% annual chance floodplain serves as collateral must have flood insurance on that structure. It can be purchased through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) or it can be bought from a different source, but insurance is mandatory or a government-regulated lender is not to issue a loan; this is federal law (42 USC 4012a). If the borrower refuses, then the lender can force place the insurance. But one way or another, the structure will have to be insured.
Understanding both the regulatory and the insurance sides of the NFIP helps us, as design professionals, to advise our clients. Often the answer to a client's question of "Can you help me get the permits for this?" is "Yes", but sometimes that answer should be qualified. Will it be worthwhile building that dream home on the beach if the insurance premiums run into thousands of dollars annually? What about rehabbing a brownfields factory to recycle it for new use when the lowest floor is seven feet below the base flood elevation of the river alongside it? While the latter is perhaps a worthy cause, it is our responsibility to advise such clients of other unexpected results of securing the building permits they seek.
Letters of Map Revision Based on Fill (LOMR-Fs) are granted for sites raised above Base Flood Elevation (BFE) after the publication of the currently effective Flood Insurance Rate Map (FIRM). The purpose of filling a site is to raise it above the risk of flooding. But in granting such waivers from mandatory flood insurance coverage, FEMA requires that the lowest floor of structures on filled sites be constructed above BFE, recognizing that it is not just surface water that poses a risk to structures. Infiltration and soil saturation pose risks to structures with basements and/or foundations below BFE, due to hydrostatic pressures. Therefore, a LOMR-F will not be issued for structures built on fill with lowest floor elevations below BFE. There is technical guidance available for building below BFE into fill in Technical Bulletin 10-01, advising of the most secure foundation types. But this is only for structural soundness, not for insurance and regulatory waivers. Such buildings are still within the 1% annual chance floodplain.
Of course, once a new FIRM is published, the area that had been considered "fill" will become a preexisting condition, and the area may no longer appear as floodplain. Doesn't this defeat the purpose of requiring permits and applications for LOMR-Fs? Filled soils do not reach the same compaction levels as natural soils, no matter how well constructed, and communities have several options to continue their oversight. After all, they are required by federal regulation (44 CFR 65.5 and 65.6) to make sure that development is "reasonably safe from flooding"*. To uphold this responsibility, communities can regulate construction in filled sites by prohibiting basements, by requiring deed restrictions that serve notice of the filled condition, and they can prohibit floodplain fill altogether. Remember that the application for a LOMR-F is through completion of the MT-1 forms that include a community acknowledgment form. There can be no sneaky midnight dirt dumping to secure the insurance waiver from FEMA.
Building in the flood fringe along an identified floodway presents a different circumstance in which elevation matters. The floodway data tables in the Flood Insurance Study (FIS) Reports provide vertical information regarding the regulatory BFE as well as the BFE that will result when the flood fringe is filled. Remember that the floodway represents the area that must be kept free of obstructions, in order to transmit the full volume of the 1% chance annual flood, computed from modeling the results of filling the floodplain from both sides to constrict the flow of water. When a computed one-foot surcharge in water surface elevation is reached in the middle unfilled area, then the limits of the floodway have been reached, and these are the lines that appear on the FIRM.
Some communities regulate more stringently and allow zero rise in water surface elevation when computing the floodway, meaning that a larger area is set aside as floodway. Whatever the local restrictions, they are reflected in the Floodway Data Table in the FIS report, which contains a listing of the BFE with and without flood fringe development. When there is a difference between these BFE figures, as there usually is, sometimes to the full foot allowed, we as design professionals should advise our clients that merely constructing to the regulatory BFE may not be adequate safeguard against flood risks. If, for instance, the regulatory BFE is 214.5 but the BFE with a floodway is 215.5, shouldn't we advise our clients to elevate their structures that extra foot? In this manner we accommodate future conditions, addressing some of the cumulative effects of construction within the floodplain.
Wendy Lathrop is licensed as a Professional Land Surveyor in NJ, PA, DE, and MD, and has been involved since 1974 in surveying projects ranging from construction to boundary to environmental land use disputes. She is a Professional Planner in NJ, and a Certified Floodplain Manager through ASFPM.
A 89Kb PDF of this article as it appeared in the magazine—complete with images—is available by clicking HERE
Editorial: Maps as a Metaphor
"I know this world is ruled by infinite intelligence. Everything that surrounds us--everything that exists--proves that there are infinite laws behind it. There can be no denying this fact. It is mathematical in its precision." There are many surveyors and mappers and members of the precision community who concur with these words of Thomas Edison. Economy, too, hangs on immutable laws. One of the .... Read the Article
Measuring a Caribbean Disaster
On January 12, 2010, a magnitude 7.0 earthquake struck the city of Port-au-Prince, the capital and largest city of Haiti. Tens of thousands of buildings collapsed, and more than 200,000 people died in the disaster. Earthquakes are not unexpected in Haiti. The country sits astride several fault lines, among them the Enriquillo-Plantain Garden fault .... Read the Article
3D-Laser Scanning and Surveying Collide
LandAir Surveying started business in 1988 performing site surveys and topographic surveys for contractors in Georgia and surrounding states with two survey crews and a total staff of less than 10. By 1998 the firm expanded to surveying cell tower sites for the telecommunications industry (more than 3,000 sites in four years) using ... Read the Article
Another Triumph!
He's done it again. Javad Ashjaee has released an impressive state-of-the-art product that enables surveyors to expand their GNSS capabilities. On June 29, 2010 Javad unveiled the Triumph VS at the company's 40,000 square foot newly designed headquarters and JAVAD EMS boardmanufacturing facility in San Jose, California. Over the decades ... Read the Article
Product Review: Hemisphere GPS R220
One of the recent trends in precision GPS manufacturing is the enclosed, fully integrated receiver. This is no doubt in response to market demands by surveyors in the field for gear that offers more durability and less complexity in setting up and getting to work. This trend has certainly offered surveyors many benefits, however, it has also ushered in a few limitations. For instance, many of these ... Read the Article
Comprehensive Collection
Recording the location, dimensions and physical attributes of every piece of equipment constituting rural utilities throughout the United States might seem like a tall order. But information tools used to build a GIS have advanced so much in recent years that the endeavor is not only possible, but plausible. Great Falls, Montana-based GeoNav Group International, Inc. recently acquired the technology to pull .... Read the Article
Feedback
Doing a Proper Job: I have a better reason for the legal profession insisting on a metes and bounds descriptions for dependent resurveys than clerk mentality or ancient check lists. In his article "Rewriting Legal Descriptions" [Vol. 7, Num. 4], Gary Kent's example of "the most egregious example of description rewriting is the preparation of a metes and bound description for a property that is a lot in ... Read the Comments
Vantage Point: "Just" What?
Several months ago my husband and I were working on a rail to trail conversion in our neighborhood, digging out debris and planting trees. At one point I was separating the junk found in the digging process from the recyclable beer cans and glass bottles when someone walked up and started talking to me. With my head still down, in the midst of trying to subdue a long strand of barbed wire into a ... Read the Article
Share this page with your favorite social networks!
Reach our audience of Professional land surveyors and Geo-Technology professionals with your career ad. Feel free to contact us if you need additional information.