About Amerisurv| Contact    
Magazine | Newsletter    
Flickr Photos | Advertise    
HomeNewsNewsletterAmerisurv DirectoryJobsStoreAuthorsHistoryArchivesBlogVideosEvents
 
advertisement


Subscriptions
Product Reviews
Software Reviews
Sponsored By

Continuing Series
     RTN
An RTN expert provides everything you need to know about network-corrected real-time GNSS observations.
Click Here to begin the series,
or view the Article PDF's Here
76-PageFlip Compilation
of the entire series
Test Yourself

Got Answers?
Test your knowledge with NCEES-level questions.
  Start HERE
Meet the Authors
Check out our fine lineup of writers. Each an expert in his or her field.
Wow Factor
Sponsored By


Partner Sites

machinecontrolonline 

LiDAR News

symbianone
lbszone.com

GISuser.com

GeoJobs.biz

GeoLearn

 

Spatial Media LLC properties

Associates

ASPRS

newsnow 

Home arrow Archives   The American Surveyor     

Vantage Point: Villain or Victim? Print E-mail
Written by Wendy Lathrop, LS, CFM   
Thursday, 26 July 2007

A 1.142Mb PDF of this article as it appeared in the magazine—complete with images—is available by clicking HERE

Like many, here is a story with two interpretations of the facts.

In 1956, John Pozsgai escaped Hungary's oppressive government and emigrated to freedom in America, settling in Morrisville, a small town in southeastern Pennsylvania.

In 1986, while considering purchase of an adjoining 14-acre site to expand his truck repair business, Pozsgai hired an engineer to examine the suitability of the site for constructing a 12,500 square-foot garage. The project would require a significant amount of filling, and in December of 1986, the consultant advised Pozsgai by letter that "Based upon this investigation, it is my professional opinion that the entire site meets the criteria set forth by the Army Corps of Engineers as `wetlands.' This is based upon soils, hydrology, and vegetation... Please be advised that any further development that might be considered on this site would have to be approved and reviewed by the Army Corps of Engineers, and it has been our experience in the past that the Corps is most reluctant to issue permits for sites that have conditions such as these."

Dissatisfied, Pozsgai hired another firm to evaluate the site, and then a third, both yielding the same assessment of restrictive wetland conditions and need for a Corps permit for any construction.

Reports in hand, Pozsgai renegotiated his contract to purchase the site, from $175,000 contingent upon Pozsgai's ability to secure a building permit for his proposed garage, down to $143,000 "as is" with no contingencies. The site became his on June 19, 1987.

However, shortly before he took title, the Army Corps of Engineers "received information" of possible illegal filling, and in April of 1987 visited and issued Pozsgai a warning, both by phone and while on site. That August, the seller of the property told the Corps that it was not he but Pozsgai who had been filling. The next month, the Corps issued a "cease and desist" order to Pozsgai. During each of two more monthly visits, the Corps found more fill. Finally, in December, a second "cease and desist" order contained two alternative resolutions: either remove all the fill, or submit a Water Quality Certification from Pennsylvania's Department of Environmental Protection.

In May of 1988, several hundred additional truckloads of fill were observed being dumped on site, and in August, after a neighbor complained about the ongoing fill activities flooding his lot, the Army Corps installed a video camera on that neighbor's property, filming an additional 25 truckloads being dumped the following week. Meanwhile, the Corps initiated a lawsuit against Pozsgai for failing to observe the cease and desist orders. By September, the federal district court issued a temporary restraining order and injunction against Pozsgai and his filling operations. In the December trial, he was found guilty on 40 charges of non-permitted discharge into wetlands, resulting in a three-year prison term, five years of probation, and $200,000 in fines ($5000 per count). Although the fine was later reduced to $5000, Pozsgai eventually served time in the federal minimum security prison at Allenwood, Pennsylvania.

In January 1990, the court issued a permanent injunction against Pozsgai, finding him in contempt of court for allowing two New Jersey hauling companies to dispose of fill, dirt, bricks, concrete, and stone in wetlands. Both haulers were also found liable; no one had a permit to discharge fill into the wetlands. In denying Pozsgai's request for a reduction of the sentence against him, the court reiterated in its March 1991 memorandum the prior court's statement that "it's hard to visualize a more stubborn violator of the laws that were designed to protect the environment."

Pozsgai petitioned for a new trial, claiming that wetlands were not protected "waters of the United States" under the jurisdiction of the Clean Water Act (CWA), because the Pennsylvania Canal into which the former (bulldozed out) stream on his land had emptied was neither used in interstate commerce nor navigable. He also claimed that the material placed in the wetlands on his property did not constitute a "discharge of pollutants into water", because the term "wetlands" does not appear in the CWA; therefore "wetlands" are not "water". Besides, he claimed, "fill" did not constitute a "pollutant". Finally, while admitting he had never acquired the state's Water Quality Certification requested by the Corps, he claimed to need only a Nationwide Permit #26. The court's June 1991 memorandum and order denied reconsideration or vacation of its January opinion.

Next the defendant tried to convince the court that the contractors (who already had paid their fines) should be required to remove the fill, and that he should have control over the restoration plan. Unsurprisingly, a February 1992 denial was confirmed by the U.S. Court of Appeals in June 1993.

While all this was occurring, private rights groups around the country noticed Pozsgai's plight and began publishing manifestos proclaiming him a victim whom the government was trying to make an example of while infringing upon his personal rights.

Finally, in March of this year, Pozsgai exhausted his legal recourses when he failed to evade the contempt charges by relying on the 2006 Rapanos v. United States decision (voiding penalties against Rapanos for filling wetlands). Environmentalists hailed the end of the line.

Here is the other side of the story, presented by Pozsgai's daughter in her testimony before the House Committee on Government Reform in October of 2000, in her unsuccessful petition for a presidential pardon.

The 14-acre site contained a stormwater drainage system dating from 1936, with a ditch that Morrisville presumably had shirked responsibility for maintaining. The result was flooding of the road and the Pozsgais' basement for twenty years, primarily due to the illegally dumped tires (about a thousand) on the lot, which he was only trying to clean up. Apparently her immigrant father did not comprehend the notices he received, while others were never delivered to him but instead to his (incompetent and intoxicated) lawyer. His misunderstanding was such that he interpreted the Army Corps' discussion of "mitigation" as a request for a bribe, which he reported to the FBI. Pozsgai's daughter testified that her father continued to receive notices of violations even after the Corps verbally confirmed that they saw no new violations.

Although some might question her account as biased, Pozsgai's daughter stated that the Army Corps and EPA should each explain their permitting procedures in simpler terms, that they should not be able to diminish a property's value by declaring it "wetlands" without compensating its owner, and that the two agencies should agree on the definition of "wetlands". She also recommended creating an independent citizens' ombudsman office with administrative authority to overrule decisions of the Army Corps and EPA regarding section 404(B) of the Clean Water Act.

Wendy Lathrop is licensed as a Professional Land Surveyor in NJ, PA, DE, and MD, and has been involved since 1974 in surveying projects ranging from construction to boundary to environmental land use disputes. She is a Professional Planner in NJ, and a Certified Floodplain Manager through ASFPM.

A 1.142Mb PDF of this article as it appeared in the magazine—complete with images—is available by clicking HERE

 

 
< Prev   Next >

 American Surveyor Recent Articles
Editorial 
Editorial: The Fire Alarm
Based on the reaction to our exposé of an attempt to remove boundary experience from the requirements to sit for a licensing exam, we seem to have struck a nerve. An educator from New Mexico chastised me for allowing the magazine to be "divisive, vilify the efforts of other ....
Read the Article
Wendy Lathrop
Vantage Point: Introducing TMAC-2
One of the closing suggestions of the first Technical Mapping Advisory Council to FEMA (TMAC-1), which convened from 1996 through 2000, was for an ongoing advisory group of technical users, something more permanent than its own five-year statutory span. The recommendations of TMAC-1 ....
Read the Article
Michael J. Pallamary, PS 
The Curt Brown Chronicles: The Future for the Land Surveyor
Curt Brown spent a considerable amount of time and energy in advancing the interests of the profession and, as he astutely noted, notwithstanding the evolution of measuring equipment, the fundamentals components of the profession merit consideration and attention. Then, as now, the future ....
Read the Article
Jason E.
Foose, PS 
The HP 35s Calculator—A Field Surveyor's Companion—Part 5- Inverse to a Line or Perpendicular Offset
This program is comparable to "inverse to line" and "station/offset" routines. The user enters a base point and defines a direction by point or azimuth, then selects a third point for reference. I use this routine frequently ....
Read the Article
Natalie Binder 
Moving London Safely Forward
Paddington Station, ­famous worldwide not only for its creator Isambard Kingdom Brunel, but also for a small marmalade loving bear. Built in 1854, Paddington Station is a fine example of an English Heritage grade 1 listed building and is site to the ....
Read the Article
Smith,
Roman, Youngman 
Recent Activities at the National Geodetic Survey—Part 2 of 4
The Gravity for the Redefinition of the American Vertical Datum (or GRAV-D) project got off the ground, literally, in 2007 when NGS's first airborne gravity flights took place. Today the GRAV-D airplanes continue to fly! With a second airborne gravimeter acquired in December 2011, NGS has been ....
Read the Article
Jerry Penry,
PS 
The Pole of Inaccessibility
The most challenging location to reach due to its remoteness from geographical features is known as a pole of inaccessibility. Generally, this calculated position is furthest from any coastline and would be the location where you would least like to be ....
Read the Article
Larry Trojak 
Use of Total Station Spawns Improvements in Salmon Monitoring Program
Think surveying equipment and it's not likely that an organization working to ensure the survival of the Pacific Northwest's salmon population comes to mind. Yet that is precisely what's ....
Read the Article
Albert “skip” Theberge 
Artillery Surveyors in WWII—Africa & Europe: Part 3: Survey Officers
Lieutenant Colonel Earle Deily, on loan from the USC&GS, was Survey Officer for the V Corps and the 17th Field Artillery Observation Battalion providing survey control to the battalion, training survey teams, and advising the V Corps Artillery Commander. He helped plan for the D-Day invasion and ....
Read the Article
Feedback 
FeedBack
I read with great interest your editorial and comments concerning Chad and Linda Erickson's article on an Idaho initiative to redefine the definition of surveying in Idaho state statutes. I am not familiar with the specifics of what is being proposed and will leave it to others to decide the ....
Read the Article
Bill Chupka,
PS 
100 Years Too Late?
There have been times in my life when I had more than just a foot in the past. Ever feel like you are one of those people who was born a hundred years too late? I remember feeling that way at times when I was young, but I was able to put all those thoughts to rest this summer over the span ....
Read the Article

deliciousrssnewsletterlinkedinfacebooktwitter

Amerisurv Exclusive Online-only Article ticker
Featured Amerisurv Events
List Your Event Here
please
contact Amerisurv


Google
 
AMERISURV TOP NEWS

30cm Satt Images
Now Available

GOT NEWS? Send To
press [at] amerisurv.com
Online Internet Content

Sponsor


News Feeds

 
Subscribe to Amerisurv news & updates via RSS or get our Feedburn
xml feed

Need Help? See this RSS Tutorial

Historic Maps
Careers

post a job
Reach our audience of Professional land surveyors and Geo-Technology professionals with your GeoJobs career ad. Feel free to contact us if you need additional information.

 

Social Bookmarks

Amerisurv on Facebook 

Amerisurv LinkedIn Group 

Amerisurv Flickr Photos 

Amerisurv videos on YouTube 

twitter

 




The American Surveyor © All rights reserved / Privacy Statement
Spatial Media LLC
905 W 7th St #331
Frederick MD 21701
301-620-0784
301-695-1538 - fax