About Amerisurv| Contact    
Magazine | Newsletter    
Flickr Photos | Advertise    
HomeNewsNewsletterAmerisurv DirectoryJobsStoreAuthorsHistoryArchivesBlogVideosEvents

Sponsored By

Software Reviews
Continuing Series
An RTN expert provides everything you need to know about network-corrected real-time GNSS observations.
Click Here to begin the series,
or view the Article PDF's Here
76-PageFlip Compilation
of the entire series
Test Yourself

Got Answers?
Test your knowledge with NCEES-level questions.
  Start HERE
Meet the Authors
Check out our fine lineup of writers. Each an expert in his or her field.
Wow Factor
Sponsored By

Product Reviews
Partner Sites







Spatial Media LLC properties




Home arrow Archives   The American Surveyor     

Thought Leader: How Good is Good Enough? Print E-mail
Written by Robert W. Foster, PE, PS   
Saturday, 02 January 2016

A 114Kb PDF of this article as it appeared in the magazine—complete with images—is available by clicking HERE

We are constantly confronted by new conceptual expressions. Some are merely expressions of enduring practices or Ideas, like "environmental pollution load," which is a fancy way of quantifying a condition of unacceptable things like dirty water and air. The term "spatial analysis tools" sounds very technically advanced but simply refers to analytical processes we are well acquainted with.

The expression "crowd sourcing" speaks of an e-process made possible by the internet connectedness that brings us all together in a manner similar to the current social networking phenomenon. Crowd sourcing makes it possible for participation of almost unlimited numbers of people in a project, like a community mapping effort, toward which contributors are invited to volunteer their knowledge and information that may not be accessible from official public sources.

"Social tenure" is a concept important in the study of occupation and possession of land in informal systems.

"Sustainability" has reached nearly cliché status. Everything today is judged for its sustainability, from the water supply in California's Central Valley to the financial/ economic system of Greece and the EU. The earliest application of the sustainability concept was in the context of the environment. We were urged to utilize our resources to meet our needs such that future generations would be able to meet their needs, as well. (Nobody talked about the fact of our generous use of resources to satisfy our wants as well as our needs.)

An expression that may be especially interesting to the United States surveying profession is "fit for purpose." This expression, in the context of surveying, expresses an objective of a process that is just right for the intended application. On its face, this does not seem to be anything new; surveyors have always applied their processes keeping in mind how the results of their work will be applied by their customers. But fit for purpose means not only of an acceptable quality e.g., good enough, but a result that is no better or greater, nor no more accurate than is needed for the intended application in order to limit cost. Therein lies the problem.

One well-respected surveying organization has as its motto, "There is no such thing as good enough." Indeed, it is in the DNA of surveyors to be always striving for improvement in what they do. One of the basic tenets of the QA/QC movement is identification of the weakest element of a process, and to improve it, on the observation that there is no perfection in any process and there is always room for improvement. This rule applies to surveying as well as to the auto industry and neurosurgery.

The-fit-for-purpose doctrine has been expressed by that community of surveyors/ mappers/GIS specialists and members of the broader "spatial data infrastructure." It is an attempt to distinguish between the tendency of the property surveyor to go to any lengths to get it right, and the compiler of a regional or national cadaster, for instance, to control cost and time. We are accustomed to spending hours researching and analyzing land tenure documents indoors, then exhaustively searching out evidence of title claims and possession in the field. The construction of a national cadaster with four dimensional characteristics cannot tolerate the kind of attention to detail the surveyor is accustomed to in her work as she exhaustively studies a single parcel to determine precise position and relationship to surrounding parcels.

The following statement taken from an article in GIM International is illuminating: "Official cadastral surveying provides authentic and certified data with a guarantee of required geometrical and attributive accuracy. This official guarantee needs to be retained since the data is essential for a country's economic development; numerous political and social decisions depend directly on it."

The American surveyor is accustomed to attaining geometrical and attributive accuracy parcel by parcel in his proprietorial work. (We are cautioned by our professional liability insurers to never offer guarantees for our services, by the way.) Rather than political and social decisions being dependent on his work, his client depends upon the surveyor's work product in order to make decisions regarding the use and marketability of the parcel in question. Therein lies the difference between the work of the typical American property surveyor and the modern cadastral surveyor: precise parcel by parcel application by the American surveyor vs multi-parcel multi-dimensional concentration by the cadastral surveyor. Which is not to say the American surveyor is not qualified to do cadastral work; but in order to do so, she must adopt the radically different "fit-for-purpose" mind-set in place of her accustomed "no such thing as good enough" ethic.

Robert W. Foster, PS, PE, of Hopkinton, MA, is in private practice, offering professional consulting services nationally in arbitration, dispute resolution and litigation involving surveying and civil engineering issues. He is past president of the International Federation of Surveyors (FIG).

A 114Kb PDF of this article as it appeared in the magazine—complete with images—is available by clicking HERE

< Prev   Next >

 American Surveyor Recent Articles
Marc Cheves, PS 
Editorial: A Great Year to be a Surveyor
Some magazines have what are called "theme" issues. That is, most of the content is focused on one particular subject. In my 22+ years of survey magazine publishing, my philosophy has always been to have a little bit of everything in each issue, thereby eliminating the possibility that ....
Read the Article
Jason E. Foose, PS 
Decided Guidance: Case Examinations: Halverson v. Deerwood Village
Whew! We really beat the snot out of Bryant v. Blevins and practical locations. Well this month we're back on new case that hit the Minnesota Supreme Court's docket in 1982. We've got the familiar gymnastics of jurisprudence featuring an extraordinary array of flying rope stretchers ...
Read the Article
Michel Philips 
Extreme Environment Surveying
A Franco-Chilean team of cave divers used the Nautiz X8 rugged handheld for marine cave surveying, gathering data to classify the inaccessible northern half of Madre de Dios for UNESCO World Heritage. The team of cave divers used the Nautiz X8 ....
Read the Article
Erik Dahlberg 
The Original Green Engineers
Sometimes, it's best just to leave things as you found them. That's the lesson shared by Dr. Richard Miksad and his students at the University of Virginia. As a result of studies covering nearly a decade, Miksad's teams have developed detailed ....
Read the Article
Dave Lindell, PS 
Test Yourself 49: No Dimensions
In square A-C-D-B with side S, C-E is tangent to the semicircle Q1 with diameter B-D. Q2 is the inscribed circle of A-C-E. The tangent to Q1 and Q2 meets the sides of the square at F and H and intersects C-E at t G. Q3 is the inscribed circle of C-G-H. What is the ratio of the radii of circles ....
Read the Article
Jerry Penry, PS 
Discovery on Grizzly Peak
When First Lieutenant Montgomery M. Macomb arrived in Carson City, Nevada, from Washington D.C., on July 28, 1878, his assigned survey crew from the 4th Artillery was waiting and ready for the new field season. At age 25, Macomb was the leader ....
Read the Article
Wendy Lathrop, PS, CFM 
Vantage Point: Fighting City Hall Over Land
Once upon a time (1989 to be exact) in a place not so far away from where I live, a man (Francis Galdo) bought a home across the street from a vacant parcel owned by the City of Philadelphia. That parcel, along with others, had been acquired by condemnation back in 1974 subsequent to a 1956 ....
Read the Article
Patrick C. Garner, PS 
Book Review: Boundary Retracement: Processes and Procedures
When I was in my mid-twenties and learning the honorable profession of land surveying, I was lucky to be guided by a mentor who would grab a book off his office shelf and say, "Every surveyor should have a copy of this!" The first example he waved at me was Davis, Foote and Kelly's Surveying ....
Read the Article


Amerisurv Exclusive Online-only Article ticker
Featured Amerisurv Events
List Your Event Here
contact Amerisurv


Carlson SurvCE &
SurvPC 6 Available

press [at] amerisurv.com
Online Internet Content


News Feeds

Subscribe to Amerisurv news & updates via RSS or get our Feedburn
xml feed

Need Help? See this RSS Tutorial

Historic Maps

post a job
Reach our audience of Professional land surveyors and Geo-Technology professionals with your GeoJobs career ad. Feel free to contact us if you need additional information.


Social Bookmarks

Amerisurv on Facebook 

Amerisurv LinkedIn Group 

Amerisurv Flickr Photos 

Amerisurv videos on YouTube 



The American Surveyor © All rights reserved / Privacy Statement
Spatial Media LLC
7820B Wormans Mill Road, #236
Frederick MD 21701
301-695-1538 - fax